How to Choose Between a Shower, Bathtub, or Both in Your Remodel
When planning a bathroom remodel, one of the biggest decisions homeowners face is choosing between a shower, a bathtub, or a combination of both. This choice isn’t just about style—it affects your home’s functionality, resale value, and daily comfort. So, how do you decide what’s right for your space and lifestyle? Let’s break it down.
- Assess Your Lifestyle and Needs
Start by thinking about how you use your bathroom. Do you rush through quick showers in the morning, or do you prefer long, relaxing soaks at the end of the day? Here are some typical scenarios:
- Busy Professionals often prefer a sleek, efficient shower.
- Families with young children benefit from having a bathtub.
- Elderly or mobility-impaired individuals may find walk-in showers with grab bars more accessible.
- Luxury lovers may want the option of both—a spa-like tub and a rainfall shower.
Understanding your habits will help you choose a layout that fits your routine.
- Consider the Space You Have
The amount of space available can limit or expand your options.
- Small Bathrooms: A shower usually takes up less room and can make the space feel more open.
- Larger Bathrooms: You might have enough square footage to install both a tub and a shower—ideal for flexibility and resale value.
If space is tight but you don’t want to give up a tub, consider a shower-tub combo. These units are versatile and practical for both bathing and quick showers.
- Think About Resale Value
If you plan to sell your home in the future, consider what potential buyers might prefer. While personal comfort should be a priority, resale is worth keeping in mind.
- A bathtub in at least one bathroom is often a must-have for families with kids.
- A modern, stylish shower might appeal more to young professionals or couples.
- A dual setup (separate shower and tub) in the primary bathroom can be a major selling point in high-end homes.
Research what’s common in homes similar to yours in your neighborhood for the best ROI.
- Evaluate Maintenance and Cleaning
Showers and bathtubs come with different cleaning commitments:
- Showers, especially frameless glass models, can require frequent wiping to avoid water spots and mildew.
- Bathtubs, especially freestanding ones, are typically easier to maintain on the exterior but may collect dust if not used regularly.
Choose a setup you’ll realistically keep clean, especially if you’re not a fan of daily maintenance.
- Don’t Forget Style and Design
The aesthetic impact of your choice also matters. Showers tend to look more modern, especially with glass doors, rainfall heads, and tiled niches. Bathtubs—especially freestanding ones—can bring a classic or luxurious touch to the room.
If your bathroom is your sanctuary, go with the option that aligns with your sense of comfort and visual style.
Final Thoughts
When choosing between a shower, bathtub, or both, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Think about your space, your lifestyle, your long-term plans, and your personal preferences. With the right planning, you can create a bathroom that not only looks great but works perfectly for you every day.
Need help with your bathroom remodel? Reach out to a local contractor or designer who can help bring your vision to life!